[Simon Royal wrote]

Hi

I have decided to buy a cheap PC laptop and run Linux on it. I was going to buy a Mac laptop - being a Mac fan, but I can get a second hand PC laptop with higher specs cheaper than a Mac one. And as it is going to run Linux it doesn't matter.

I have been told IBM Thinkpads are good for Linux can anyone recommend anything in particular?

Also I want to buy a wireless PCMCIA card that will work on a laptop and under Linux, any suggestions?

I agree that Thinkpads are an excellent choice, both in general and for Linux in particular.

For wireless, some web research told me that any card with an Atheros chipset should be supported by my distro- Kubuntu Breezy- so I ordered a 3Com Office Connect Xjack 3CRXJK10075 11g card from Amazon for just under £40. This worked out of the box beautifully. It has a retractable arial, so no awkward protrusion when not in use. Pushing the arial in also turns off power to the card. The only downside is a flashing green LED that you could use to guide in an aircraft- but a small piece of black insulation tape cures this.

The card is actually easier to use in Ubuntu than in XP, which I have on the same machine as a dual boot. I think that maybe this is because installing the 3Com software was a mistake. Anyway, just getting it to connect is rather clunky.

Opting for Thinkpad also means that you can take advantage of a lot of helpful stuff that others have written on the web about their experiences with linux. There are also packages written specifically for the machine to get features such as volume on-sreen display and trackpoint configuration working. The first of these is easily accessible from the Ubuntu repositories. The other requires a little fiddling with kernel patches.

Trackpoint is so splendid imho, that I wouldn't buy another laptop without it. The relative 'stickyness' of its functioning in Ubuntu is one of the very few downsides compared to Windows. So even though I am probably the least technically able person on this list by a long way I'm going to try and do the kernel patching. Or at least I would if I didn't suspect that the patch will be included in the kernel that ships with Dapper. On the downside this will mean compiling driver modules for the built in winmodem again- but if I can do it anyone can.

The Thinkpad I have by the way is a T22, PIII 900MHz 256MB purchased from ebay second hand for about £305 including shipping in 2004. The only upgrade I've done is to replace the 20G HD with a 60G one when it burnt out. A lovely keyboard for typing and a nice sharp display. Case has cracked near the DVD/floppy drive bay: my holding it by the front edge probably contributed to this.

Now the thing is working pretty beautifully with Kubuntu. Plays most DVDs (mission-critical as I have no TV) using Mplayer, which also records audio streams like BBC, all my mp3s with Amarok, opens Word, Excel and Powerpoint files from work... if only shockwave and some decent qualitative research software were available for linux things would be perfect.

By the way, if you do decide to give the 3Com card a try, make sure that you check that the precise model you go for has actually got a supported chipset like Atheros- that is why I gave the full part spec above.

Best wishes,

Rob