On 15-Feb-05 Anthony Anson wrote:
Does anybody recommend anyone?
Zetnet, with no qualms. One of the directors is a Debian developer, too.
Have a look at www.zetnet.com
Zetnet's the oldest independent ISP in Britain, established in Lerwick ten years ago. Closed (to non-Zetnuts) newsgroups, child-friendly policy, Littlehat Proxy server and under-18 newsgroup list for anklebiters, supports Win, Linux, Risc OS, and ISTR BBC and others have been/are being used.
[NB this is not about broadband but about "which ISP for dialup"]
I've been aware of Zetnet for years (since a friend in Caithness has been on it) -- and, by the way, in those days at least some of Zetnet's hardware was in Manchester (where I was at the time). They certainly have seemed to offer a quality service.
Your response above prompted me to look at them again, since I'm currently p***ed off with BTopenworld (yet again).
BTOW's service is OK most of the time (with occasional DNS problems and other things that shouldn't happen in a properly maintained system), but the thing about them that really comes home to roost is that their SMTP service seems to be completely open relay.
Once dialled in to their ISP service, it's no problem to send anyone a message from (say) "Zaphod.Beeblebrox@cosmos.god.org" (not making this up -- I've done it as a test) by doing an SMTP dialogue with their SMTP server, with "helo" from some nonsense address. The only thing that would stop this getting through would be a block at the receiving end.
I'm re-p***ed off because I've just had a message to Salford University bounced because the BT dial-up IP address used at the time was blacklisted ("550-Your email has been blocked, because it was delivered to us from an address that may be a source of spam email" -- and no wonder!)
I worked round this by logging in to my still existing Manchester University account and sending from there while on line, but this is not how I like to work, especially when this involves exchanges of messages. Normally, my MUA does the SMTP sending of messages which I've quietly composed off-line and at leisure. The MU option is most smoothly worked by creating a local text file of the message to be sent and pasting this into the xterm which is logged in to MU. This is also unduly complicated, though (and it's a bugger for attachments)!
My problem with changing ISP, though, is that at present my BTOW account, for a fairly modest monthly fee (£16/month), gives me free dialling from my BT line, and as much as I ever want to use of cost-free on-line time. So I'd want the same from a new ISP.
I went to the Zetnet website http://www.zetnet.com, and looked around for the sort of thing described above. Most of what they offer seems to be "0845 connecivity" which, with the way I use the Net, would run up big call charges.
However, it is possible to track down "0800 free call" connections, on the web page
http://www.zetnet.com/internetservices/connections/flatrate/0800.htm
However, when I read this, it's not as cheap as you might expect. Quotation:
The 0800 service enables customers to connect from any phone line in the UK free of charge for a flat monthly rate. Ideal for any business users who are traveling with mobile PC's and those making regular hotel visits. The service allows full, high quality access to the Internet through Zetnet's network.
You have a choice of free numbers: 0800, which works from any line, or 08089, which only works from BT lines. The 08089 number has one rate (1 unit per minute) that applies at any time. The 0800 number is charged at different rates depending on time of day. Peak rate is from 8am to 6pm on weekdays.
The 0800/08089 service is available as an upgrade to any of our packages (one account per package only).
Package Requirement Inclusive Time Monthly Charge (inc VAT) Basic or Above 600 units Peak 0800 - 48 seconds = 2 units £5.00 Off Peak 0800 - 48 seconds = 1 unit (£5.88) Anytime 08089 - 60 seconds = 1 unit
So for £6/month it seems I can get 600 minutes = 10 hours using 08089 with my BT line. My monthly on-line time for January was 90 hours, which at the above rate would have cost me £45 as opposed to the £16 flat rate per month I pay to BT (and I could have used it for longer). (Part of the reason for these long times is of course the fact that I can't get any broadband so am stuck with about 3K bytes/sec which is dire for the large downloads I need quite often: 3K/sec => 350sec/MB ~= 6min/MB).
In other words, the Zetnet service is basically a flat rate for very modest use (up to 600 min/month = 20min/day), but for the sort of usage I have (about 3hr/day) is pretty much a pro-rata charge of 1p/minute. On that basis, 10MB PDF or .tgz files would on average cost me 60p each.
Also, I can't find out whether, once you go over the 600min limit, you can extend this Zetnet service as much as you like for the same price (or less) per 600min.
I'd be grateful for any informed comment on the above reflections.
Of course, one option to work round the mail-block problem would be to keep the BTOW account for time-consuming net browsing, downloads, etc., and just use the Zetnet account (for an extra £6/month) to send mail using my MUA's SMTP mechanism. Even this, though, could puch up against the basic 600min/month = 20min;/day Zetnet limit, especially when I have to send attachments.
And it would turn out to be equally useless if Zetnet's numbers were ever blacklisted! So: are they?
With thanks, and best wishes to all, Ted.
-------------------------------------------------------------------- E-Mail: (Ted Harding) Ted.Harding@nessie.mcc.ac.uk Fax-to-email: +44 (0)870 094 0861 Date: 16-Feb-05 Time: 10:08:39 ------------------------------ XFMail ------------------------------